A hydraulic chuck and a shrink-fit holder both grip a plain cylindrical shank directly, with no collet between the holder and the tool. Both are chosen for finishing, where concentricity and balance decide the surface and the life of the edge.
They differ in how the grip is made, and in what each asks of the tool room. On an HSK63A spindle the choice usually comes down to how often tools are changed, and how far the tool has to reach.
How a hydraulic chuck grips
Turning the clamping screw drives a piston into a sealed oil chamber. The pressure deflects a thin expansion sleeve evenly around the shank, and the sleeve holds the tool along its full clamping length.
A hex key is the only tool needed, so a tool can be changed at the machine. The oil film also damps vibration, which shows on a finishing pass and when reaming. Shanks should be ground to h6.
How a shrink-fit holder grips
The bore of a shrink-fit holder is slightly smaller than the shank it takes. An induction unit heats the nose until the bore opens enough for the shank to slide in. As the holder cools, it contracts onto the tool.
With no screws, sleeves or moving parts, the holder is symmetrical and balances well at high spindle speeds. The nose can be made slim, which lets a long tool reach into a deep cavity without the holder touching the wall. The cost is the induction unit, and the minutes a holder needs to cool before it goes back into the magazine.
Choosing for a finishing pass
Where tools are changed often at the machine, or where the shop has no induction unit, the hydraulic chuck is the practical choice, and its damping helps on long finishing passes and reaming.
Where the tool has to reach past a wall, or the spindle runs fast enough that balance starts to matter, a shrink-fit holder is the better fit. Many shops run both, and set the choice by operation.
In the catalogue
Kawacut lists 9 HSK63A hydraulic chucks, Ø6 to Ø32, and 22 HSK63A shrink-fit holders, Ø4 to Ø32. For BT spindles there are 47 hydraulic chucks from BT30 to BT50.